It has been suggested that an early draft of the Donation of Constantine was made shortly after the middle of the 8th century, in order to assist Pope Stephen II in his negotiations with Pepin the Short , who then held the position of Mayor of the Palace i. In one study, an attempt was made at dating the forgery to the 9th century, and placing its composition at Corbie Abbey , in northern France. Mediaevalist Johannes Fried draws a distinction between the Donation of Constantine and an earlier, equally forged version, the Constitutum Constantini , which was included in the collection of forged documents, the False Decretals , compiled in the later half of the ninth century.
Fried argues the Donation is a later expansion of the much shorter Constitutum.
Much more than documents.
Christopher B. He cited a large portion of the document, believing it genuine, furthering the debate that would ultimately lead to the East—West Schism. In the 11th and 12th centuries, the Donation was often cited in the investiture conflicts between the papacy and the secular powers in the West. Few centuries later in his De Monarchia , Dante Alighieri, although he did not consider the Constitutum Constantini false in his time the falsity had not yet been demonstrated , denied its legal value, since with it the emperor had caused damage to the Roman Empire, thus fulfilling an act contrary to its institutional duties.
In fact, the poet claimed that neither had Constantine the right to donate to third parties the territories belonging to the Empire, nor could a pope understand them among his possessions, as he would be contravening the New Testament precepts regarding the obligation of poverty for the Church, but at most , could have accepted the gift as a usufructuary. Basically, Dante judged the donation as an invalid act, criticizing the Church for having taken it as legal proof of its temporal power. It was not until the midth century, with the revival of Classical scholarship and textual criticism, that humanists, and eventually the papal bureaucracy, began to realize that the document could not possibly be genuine.
Cardinal Nicholas of Cusa declared it to be a forgery and spoke of it as an apocryphal work.
- Textausgabe + Lektüreschlüssel. Friedrich Schiller: Der Verbrecher aus verlorener Ehre: Reclam Textausgabe + Lektüreschlüssel (German Edition)?
- La donazione di Costantino. Testo latino a fronte PDF - PDF.
- Individual Offers.
- Taylor & Francis Social Science & Humanities.
- Uploaded by.
Later, the Catholic priest Lorenzo Valla argued in his philological study of the text that the language used in manuscript could not be dated to the 4th century. The language of the text suggests that the manuscript can most likely be dated to the 8th century. Valla believed the forgery to be so obvious that he leaned toward believing that the Church had knowledge that the document was inauthentic. This was the first instance of modern, scientific diplomatics.
Also, the purported date of the document is inconsistent with the content of the document itself, as it refers both to the fourth consulate of Constantine as well as the consulate of Gallicanus Pope Pius II wrote a tract in , five years before becoming Pope, to show that, though the Donation was a forgery, the papacy owed its lands to Charlemagne and its powers of the keys to Peter ; he did not publish it, however. For a book I had to read for school, this wasn't too bad. Valla had no shame in standing up to the papacy back in his day.
- A Rear View Mirror of My Life!
- Content Metrics.
- Log in to Wiley Online Library.
- Il passaggio (Omnibus) (Italian Edition);
It was actually quite comical to read because he would be intelligently analyzing the donation and then all of a sudden say something like "so this is why you would have to be an idiot to believe this is true". Honestly, a lot of what he says about people in power lying to get what they want and people believing it because they don't know better is something relatable throug For a book I had to read for school, this wasn't too bad.
Abrahamic Religions Study Hall: Jews, Christians, and Muslims, same Faith same Studies.
Honestly, a lot of what he says about people in power lying to get what they want and people believing it because they don't know better is something relatable through the ages. We have our on "Donation of Constantine"s even now. I probably took a star off because it was a school read so I wasn't as engaged as I would've been had I picked it up on my own though I probably wouldn't have picked it up then.
Jul 31, Ike Sharpless rated it it was amazing Shelves: reviewed , italiano , classics. Valla's book captures the essence of the critical humanism that was beginning to bloom again in the Italian renaissance. He uses deft historiographic and philological footwork to determine that 'il dono di costantino' was a forgery. Very important work of early history. Lorenzo Valla uses logic, philosophical argument, a thorough knowledge of Roman history, and a classical education steeped in Latin literature to prove that the Donation of Constantine, a centuries-old document in which Emperor Constantine cedes his power to Pope Sylvester, was a forgery.
The text of the Coleman translation or really any translation of Valla is difficult not because of the prose, but because of the assumed knowledge of Roman history and th Very important work of early history. The text of the Coleman translation or really any translation of Valla is difficult not because of the prose, but because of the assumed knowledge of Roman history and the classics on the part of the reader.
- Just Us Guys: Saga 1?
- The Wright Way: 7 Problem-Solving Principles from the Wright Brothers That Can Make Your Business Soar?
- Financial Condition of Depository Banks?
- With Lee in Virginia; A Story Of The American Civil War : complete with original Illustration and Writer Biography (Illustrated);
There is much that cannot be appreciated without doing a deep-dive into the Latin literature of the Dark and Middle Ages. Still, Valla unleashes some hilarious criticisms and shows his frustration about the longstanding hoax, as well as his annoyance that multiple popes would cite the Donation of Constantine as support for their Earthly power.
Project MUSE - Periodical Literature
A truly brilliant analysis of the medieval papal forgery of "The Donation of Constantine", credited with really popularizing philology at the beginning of the Renaissance. Despite the erudition of the work, Valla's sarcastic phrasing often leaves much to be desired. Recommended for its historical significance. Mar 21, Nathan rated it really liked it.
Brilliant exposure of medieval papal forgery by means historical, philological, legal, and logical. Ironically Valla would go on to work for the Vatican. Ryan rated it liked it Nov 22, Tyrel rated it liked it Jan 20, Titas K. Adam rated it it was amazing Aug 26, Paolo D'alonzo rated it liked it Oct 18, Branko rated it really liked it Jun 02, Stark rated it really liked it Jun 18, Inti Willka rated it it was amazing May 25, Pullan, La politica sociale Maschio , Investimenti edilizi Arnaldi e M.
Pastore Stocchi a cura di , Storia della cultura veneta. Glixon, L. Cesco, L.
General and Miscellaneous
Urban a cura di , La Scuola Grande di san Rocco nella musica e nelle feste veneziane , Venezia, , p. Maschio, Investimenti edilizi Pavanini, Abitazioni popolari e borghesi nella Venezia Cinquecentesca , in Studi veneziani , 5, V, , p. Pullan, Abitazioni al servizio dei poveri nella Repubblica di Venezia , in G. Gianighian e P. Pavanini a cura di , Dietro i palazzi.
Tre secoli di architettura minore a Venezia , Venezia, , p. Tafuri, Venezia e il Rinascimento Tafuri, Ricerca del Rinascimento. Boucheron e M. Folin a cura di , I grandi cantieri del rinnovamento urbano esperienze italiane ed europee a confronto secoli xiv-xvi c. Struttura e funzioni , Venezia, , p. Pullan, The Scuole Grandi of Venice Sulle vicende costruttive della Scuola, P.
Soravia, Le chiese di Venezia descritte ed illustrate , vol. Nicoletti, Illustrazione della Chiesa e Scuola di S. III, , p. Gentili in Venezia Cinquecento , 1, , p. Su Caravia e sul cenacolo degli evangelici veneziani si vedano M. Firpo, Artisti, gioielleri, eretici. Il mondo di Lorenzo Lotto tra Riforma e Controriforma.
Morresi, Cittadini-architetti? Francesco Feletto guardian grande evangelico, Tiziano e Sansovino , in A. Calzona, F. Fiore, A.